Categories
Kusen

436. Practice Enlightenment

One of the many difficult to understand – and difficult to accept – ideas in Dogen’s Zen is that of practice enlightenment, the idea that practice and realisation aren’t the same, but they’re not separate either, and they arise together. Difficult because it goes against the easy to understand idea that awakening/enlightenment/realisation is the outcome of practice. This is frequently and capitalistically promoted by all the crappy stuff we get about so called enlightenment intensives, how to get 20 years worth of practice in one weekend, provided you pay a certain amount of money. All that bullshit is predicated on the [common sense but wrong] idea that you do something to get something.

But if we to take the other [obvious but wrong] perspective about practice enlightenment, then we’re likely to fall into a weird mysticism, which we can’t really accept, because it’s not true. So it’s helpful to think in terms of our actual experience to investigate what practice enlightenment might mean.

In my opinion, for almost all of our lives, we’re in a trance. We think we’re seeing reality, but we aren’t. We’re seeing a world constructed by culture, language, and our personal and societal karma. But when we sit in zazen, alongside all the noise and confusion, we can experience, right now, the non separation between ourselves and the environment. We can feel right now that that spaciousness that we experience isn’t some psychological ‘spaciousness’ in my head, or not just that, it’s a spaciousness which connects and contains everything. And we can also see that the self doesn’t exist in the way in which we ordinarily take it, although it’s plain in meditation that a kind of selfing activity is going on quite a lot of the time.

What happens is that when we try and relate this experience of non-duality to other people or to ourselves, then in that linguistic re -creation of the experience, we render it in terms which are either mystical and poetical, or more commonly, which reaffirm the self and reaffirm duality. So we’ll say, oh, I had this experience where I felt very spacious, rather than something like:spaciousness appeared and it felt that everything was within it, or something like that. So in a way, in an ordinary way, not a special mystical way, in an ordinary way, we wake up during zazen and often when we go back to our lives, apart from that, we fall back into a trance. 

And part of the issue is that we think that enlightenment or awakening is a quality of the person, and hence once it arises it persists. But it is not a quality of the person, it is a quality of the moment, it is momentary. The moment is enlightened, the moment is awakened, and the moment is non-dual. That’s what we need to understand. And I say we go back into a trance rather than fall back asleep or go into a dream because our dreams are miracles, they are miracles of the heart expressing itself. Trance isn’t like that, because within it the grey miasma of words and concepts and separation occlude this miracle of aliveness.