Categories
Kusen

431. What is dropping off body?

Master Dogen described the practice of zazen as being the [continuous process of] ‘dropping off body and mind’. 

It’s reasonably clear what he meant by dropping off mind, because he describes that process in quite a straightforward way in Genjokoan: in zazen, we allow all our experience to live fully, unconstrained by the assumption of ownership of this experience by the self.

That is, all the multifaceted aspects of our experience can be expressed, and they don’t have to be stuffed into the small jar of self. Sometimes that is expressed in spatial terms. So we’ll say it’s as if in zazen our awareness is like vast space, within which everything can freely appear, manifest itself entirely then go.

And if we do not give attention to the body, people can quite often have the notion that this sense of vast spaciousness, once developed, is the same as non-duality. That if zazen had a destination, this would be it.

Yet that’s incorrect, because it excludes the actual fabric of being; this body and all others.

Dropping off body is more difficult for us to understand, but it needn’t be. It is simply to forgo an unconscious yet pernicious idea we have of the body as being like an object within consciousness.

Or another way of putting it is as being like a pictured body within the mind: when someone asks us to pay attention to our left hand, do we sense it, or do we look at it?

Dropping off body is dropping off that conceptual sense of the body, so we can actually experience it as it is phenomenologically. And what we notice when we’re sitting in zazen is that very often we will experience our body as being like charged space.

So it’s there [as a ‘something’] but  not there. And there isn’t a clear boundary between body and world. There’s not a clear demarcation between this body and the body of all being.

And that is a much more immediate and natural sense of non-duality, which is beginningless and endless.

Categories
Kusen

432. What is meant by ‘Dharma Position’?

In Dogen’s Genjokoan, there’s the following highly evocative passage. (using the Okumura translation)

“Firewood becomes ash. Ash cannot become firewood again. However, we should not view ash as after and firewood as before. We should know that firewood dwells in the Dharma position of firewood and has its own before and after. Although before and after exist, past and future are cut off. Ash stays in the position of ash with its own before and after.”

The material phrase in this passage is ‘Dharma Position’, (in Japanese) “hōi”. What does Dogen mean by Dharma Position? We can gain some understanding if we consider our actual experience in zazen. 

Sometimes it’s as if we’re experiencing ourselves and the whole world as one piece.

There isn’t an inner and an outer. There is just oneness. Obviously, there’s differentiation. But there isn’t duality. And from that actual experience, we can see that in this moment nothing is excluded. In this moment, there are congregations of expressions and activities. There is this person sitting, there’s the birds singing, there is light falling through rain, there is dharma rain making our obstinacy more pliable. And we can see that, in this single moment, absolutely everything is included: all being, all moments.What’s meant by Dharma Position is an actual occurrence in the present moment, which we can think of as a moment of experience, a moment of activity, a moment of expression; something like that. 

But what we don’t think of it as is a moment of activity in or from or by a being which continues from past to present to future. The example, which Dogen is using about firewood and ash, says that in our unexamined normal way of thinking, there’s an underlying something [never specified] which is first a seed, and then a young tree, and then a mature tree and then firewood and then ash. Of course, whilst Dogen is using a poetic example he’s really talking about your ash: your birth, your life, your death.

And the suggestion is that although in one sense, to organise things, it’s convenient for us to think that there’s a continuity, which we achieve by fracturing experience into objects that persist over time, in a deeper sense and in a sense which is essential to enable us to understand the depth of our life, there isn’t a continuity of an underlying essence. So, as it were, all the moments, of this life, of your life, of everyone’s life are separate and distinct, but also connected with all being and all moments as moments. There’s not an underlying continuity of beings in time. Of course, each Dharma Position is part of the tapestry of being/time. There appears to be a contradiction, but there really isn’t. And Dogen is drawing out the implications of the perspective of ‘no-self’, which is the founding insight of Buddhism.

To reconfigure the world as not as cause and effect between ongoing entities but rather an ongoing miracle of expression, of exertion, of experience. 

Categories
Kusen

433. Living Within Miracles

A monk asked Yunmen, “Where is the place the Buddhas go beyond Buddhahood?” Yunmen answered “Where the east mountain walks on water.”

 When we hear this – if we assume that Yunmen’s answer isn’t intentionally nonsensical – we’ll try and decode it. So we may say, “Well, the mountain is the symbol of the whole world of interdependence, which is flowing,like water would flow”; an early version of the process view.” 

But what we don’t do is take the image seriously. Which is strange because many of us have had the experience of being in a boat on water, looking over at a mountain, and it appears that the mountain is walking on water. We have these magical experiences all the time. So, for instance, at this time of year in the early dusk, before people close the curtains and the lights are on internally, there’s an extraordinary mirror effect on the windows, intermingling inside and outside.

We can think of other examples. But what we would say is that this phenomenological world, where we appear to see magical things, where we appear to be living within miracles is just something that’s going on inside us. And what we do to eradicate those miracles is that we superimpose upon the world of our experience a conceptual world, which we call reality.

So we say “There’s a mountain over there. It’s not doing anything. It’s not walking on water. There’s the sky, there’s the water.”, and so on. What we need to understand is that our universe is not made up of lots of things acting on each other. It is a living dynamic whole, full of perspective and full of expression. And that perspective that we have of seeing the mountain walk on water is not some odd psychological thing that’s happening internal to us. It’s part of the dynamic expression of the whole universe. That relationship that we have with the mountain is part of the expressive creativity of the mountain. If we understand that and do not flatten our experience with this concretising ‘reality’, then we can live within miracles.

Categories
Kusen

434. Mind Is World

When the Chinese Zen masters make statements like ‘Mind is world’, they don’t mean that another world [or this one] is somehow inside your mind. They’re not taking an idealist position. They’re saying that everything is of one fabric, that the distinction we make between self and world, between thought and world, is incorrect.

It’s often difficult for us to understand what these masters are talking about, because one of the primary influences on classical Chinese Zen is Yogacara. And Yogacara, which has been mischaracterised as ‘mind only’, tends to be missed out from the influences on Zen. We think of Nagarjuna, of the movement around Buddha nature, of the Tiantai school, of the Huayan school; but we don’t think of Yogacara.

And until Professor Waldron’s recent book [‘Making Sense of Mind Only’], there’s actually very little in English for the general public about Yogacara. And that’s very unfortunate. Because Yogacara has a whole vision of mind, consciousness and world, which is extremely applicable to our practice.

One of the points that Yogacara  makes is that in the act of perception, both the object and the subject appear.

When I see something, when my, in their language, eye consciousness is engaged, both the flower appears, but also, as it were, the person appears.

The person who’s seeing the flower is not pre-existing. Although we can grasp that in theory, the tendency that we have is to say, well in this moment, I’m obviously seeing something. I might be mis-seeing it, or other creatures might see it differently. But there is a definite something ‘out there’ seen by an ongoing person ‘in here’,

So we can understand the point [which is same point that neuroscience would make] but we immediately undercut it by grafting on top an assumption that there is a real world out there.

And the value of meditation is that the ‘mental objects’ which appear when we’re meditating  -the thoughts, the emotions, the memories, the internal chatter. which create and maintain the self from moment to moment- it’s much clearer to see those as constructs, as not really existing. When we experience a thought, it’s easy, or or at least easier to move from what Yogacara would call the imaginary state where, as it were, I’m just seeing things [‘out there’] to the dependent state which understands that one thing is arising in consequence of many other things.

This particular thought is arising because of experiences that I had today; because of indigestion, because I’m irritated by the noise of traffic, or whatever. So, meditation helps us shift from a state of, as it were, naive realism which initially we perpetuate in meditation, thinking the contents of our experience come pre-formed and exist. [as they appear] It helps us move from that position to one of dependent origination. And from that position, it becomes easier to move into what Yogacara called the third state, which is the true state, which is that reality is ineffable. And so as it were, we see [ the flower] in two ways. We see it in its conventional form. There’s a flower, there’s a thought,there’s a mountain, and we see it in its vastness, its ineffability.

And so it’s very unfortunate that Yogacara is missed out of the influences on Zen that people acknowledge because when it is missed out, the risk is that we misunderstand the purpose of meditation. In error we think of it primarily in terms of psychological wellness, in terms of calming the mind, in terms of suppressing thought and inducing a state of contemplative peace, [or insight into emptiness] rather than addressing the fundamental cause of suffering: the assumed duality of self and world. And the overcoming of that duality is not to create a nihilistic state, but to create a state of vibrant aliveness. That we have, and always have had, but forget.

Categories
Kusen

435. Buddha Nature

The single most important idea in Chinese Buddhism, and hence in Zen, is Buddha nature. And it has a historical context. 

The three strands that make up Chinese Buddhism in its initial period are Nagarjuna, Yogacara, and a clutch of sutras, which don’t appear to have specific  schools attached to them, but which centre around the theme of Buddha nature. 

And we can see in a way these three aspects are sequential in that Yogacara is correcting an erroneous reading of Nagarjuna, and some themes in Yogacara are then developed in Buddha Nature thinking.

Nagarjuna’s destruction of all our conceptual apparatus in the affirmation of emptiness was meant to clear the ground for us to live a life that is more connected, more within the world, and more alive. The problem is that from the get go, many people misinterpreted Nagarjuna in a nihilistic way, because the positive aspect was left implicit.

So Yogacara, which comes a little bit after Nagarjuna, is a corrective to that, in several ways. It creates a very elaborate Buddhist theory of consciousness, and instead of emptiness it talks about suchness. It says we can be in three states. We can be in an illusory state where we’re just seeing the world in a conceptual way. We can see the world as dependently originated. And we can see the world as thusness, the third stage. Seeing the world as dependent, particularly during meditation, is a bridge to thusness. But Yogacara doesn’t really detail, possibly for the same reasons as Nagarjuna, the positive aspect of the doctrine, what thusness is, because explaining something leads you to the errors of conceptualising and comparing it, thinking there is a standard that you’ve got to reach and so on. So Buddha nature then comes along and fleshes out this idea of thusness in a series of positive attributes.

The problem that we have then, from our Zen perspective, is that these three tendencies, which are put together in texts like the Lankavatara Sutra, which then feed into the creation of the  indigenous Chinese schools of Tiantai and Huayan, which leads to Zen in due course are, apart from Nagarjuna, largely forgotten. The Yogacara school disappears due to a disagreement about the extent and universality of Buddha nature, and the Buddha Nature orientation was never a school in the first place.

And so, ironically, the person who these tendencies were meant to fix, or fix an erroneous interpretation of, Nagarjuna, is the guy that remains most visible in the Zen tradition. And this makes it very difficult, I think, for us to understand the significance of Buddha nature thinking, creating a sort of bemused embarrassment, of thinking it’s quaint and Chinese rather than grappling with something absolutely essential for us and which deserves our sustained attention.

Categories
Kusen

436. Practice Enlightenment

One of the many difficult to understand – and difficult to accept – ideas in Dogen’s Zen is that of practice enlightenment, the idea that practice and realisation aren’t the same, but they’re not separate either, and they arise together. Difficult because it goes against the easy to understand idea that awakening/enlightenment/realisation is the outcome of practice. This is frequently and capitalistically promoted by all the crappy stuff we get about so called enlightenment intensives, how to get 20 years worth of practice in one weekend, provided you pay a certain amount of money. All that bullshit is predicated on the [common sense but wrong] idea that you do something to get something.

But if we to take the other [obvious but wrong] perspective about practice enlightenment, then we’re likely to fall into a weird mysticism, which we can’t really accept, because it’s not true. So it’s helpful to think in terms of our actual experience to investigate what practice enlightenment might mean.

In my opinion, for almost all of our lives, we’re in a trance. We think we’re seeing reality, but we aren’t. We’re seeing a world constructed by culture, language, and our personal and societal karma. But when we sit in zazen, alongside all the noise and confusion, we can experience, right now, the non separation between ourselves and the environment. We can feel right now that that spaciousness that we experience isn’t some psychological ‘spaciousness’ in my head, or not just that, it’s a spaciousness which connects and contains everything. And we can also see that the self doesn’t exist in the way in which we ordinarily take it, although it’s plain in meditation that a kind of selfing activity is going on quite a lot of the time.

What happens is that when we try and relate this experience of non-duality to other people or to ourselves, then in that linguistic re -creation of the experience, we render it in terms which are either mystical and poetical, or more commonly, which reaffirm the self and reaffirm duality. So we’ll say, oh, I had this experience where I felt very spacious, rather than something like:spaciousness appeared and it felt that everything was within it, or something like that. So in a way, in an ordinary way, not a special mystical way, in an ordinary way, we wake up during zazen and often when we go back to our lives, apart from that, we fall back into a trance. 

And part of the issue is that we think that enlightenment or awakening is a quality of the person, and hence once it arises it persists. But it is not a quality of the person, it is a quality of the moment, it is momentary. The moment is enlightened, the moment is awakened, and the moment is non-dual. That’s what we need to understand. And I say we go back into a trance rather than fall back asleep or go into a dream because our dreams are miracles, they are miracles of the heart expressing itself. Trance isn’t like that, because within it the grey miasma of words and concepts and separation occlude this miracle of aliveness.

Categories
Kusen

437. Polishing A Tile

One of the most famous koans is ‘polishing a tile’. In the most common version Master Baso, probably the greatest of all the Chinese Zen Masters, is a student of Master Nangaku. Baso is assiduously practicing zazen, and one day Nangaku seeing Baso (in Zazen) says something like, ‘What are you aiming at practicing zazen?’ And Baso says ‘I’m aiming to become a Buddha.’ Nangaku then picks up a tile lying on the ground, and starts polishing it against a rock. And Baso says in (apparent) astonishment, ‘What are you doing?’ Nangaku says ‘I’m polishing a tile to make a mirror.’ And Baso says ‘How can you make a tile into a mirror by polishing it?’ or something like that. And Nangaku says ‘Likewise, how can you make a human being into a Buddha?’

So to understand this koan, it’s helpful to start with a couple of things. Firstly, the tile here is symbolic of  a karmic human being. The mirror is symbolic of Buddhahood or Buddha nature. And polishing is the act of zazen. It’s also helpful to know that in China at that time, mirrors were generally made of metals such as bronze which required to be polished to create the mirror and to be kept polished to maintain the mirror. So that’s one thing. The second thing is we should pay careful attention to exactly what Nangaku said. So Baso hears Nangaku as saying, ‘I’m polishing this tile to make this tile into a mirror’, but that’s actually not what he says. Nangaku says ‘I’m polishing a tile to make a mirror’, not (necessarily) to make this [or another] tile a mirror, but ‘I’m polishing a tile to make a mirror’. 

So, in other words, tile or karmic human being and mirror, Buddhahood, don’t obstruct each other. They don’t collapse into each other. One doesn’t become the other. They don’t occupy the same existential space. And all of this makes sense when viewed through Huayan philosophy and specifically its ideas of interdependence, because everything is empty, and because emptiness is indivisible. Thus each thing is everything. Each thing is every other thing, and each thing also occupies its own distinctive place. So within that logic, human beings, vulnerable human beings practicing zazen, and Buddhas keep their place, one doesn’t become the other. But within this totality, they coexist. And the picture of the Huayan universe, which can sometimes be quite static; the most common image that is used is that of Indra’s Net, is rendered dynamic through the act of polishing.

So it’s not that Buddha nature/mirror is just there somewhere, and it’s just for us to stumble upon it. It’s actualised. It’s manifested by our effort in zazen. Now from our feeble karmic position, of course, we can’t see this. But it seems to me that in some sense, we can intuit something of it. But it also seems that we require for some of our journey and perhaps forever, faith.